A friend of mine was discussing my first post about flat taxes and was in fact one of the people that pointed out that poor people are more greatly affected by these concepts than the rest. He seemed to think I had no concept about what being poor was or that I was dismissing legitimate claims. Later in an effort to enlighten me, he sent me the following link: http://www.scalzi.com/whatever/003704.html
This is a good look into the life of a poor person, so much so that it stirred some memories from my own childhood. Although some of these lines are particularly disturbing, none quite so much as this.
- Being poor is having to live with choices you didn’t know you made when you were 14 years old.
This is the one line that has incredible truth for me. I made many mistakes around this age and looking back I did a great deal of teetering and somehow managed to avoid the pitfalls I toyed with. A great deal of things “worked out” for me for no apparent reason. Was it karma, upbringing or perhaps God? I can’t say, but I can say having been through some of that shit, it sucks…Hard!
It’s not fair to say I know being poor, because every degree of poor is different and we all have personal weaknesses in specific areas. However, before any more of you start thinking that I had it easy and that I don’t fully appreciate the poor’s position in life, let me give you a few gems from my life.
- Being poor is having to crap in a hole in the ground and when the tp runs out, use a leaf.
- Being poor is eating ramon noodles for three meals a day.
- Being poor is learning the park ranger schedules so that you can take a shower with warm water.
- Being poor is taking cold showers under a spring fed water fall when the park is closed.
- Being poor is sleeping in a tent 4 feet from a dirt road, with a nice comfy tree root for a pillow.
- Being poor is having to walk 8 miles home after the 1.5 hour bus trip after school.
- Being poor is feeling fortunate enough to be treated to a fast food restaurant for my 16 birthday.
- Being poor is behaving yourself when all the adults go to work. Social Services be damned!!
Perhaps because I was a kid it was little different for me, but I’m going to take a wild guess and say that besides the stress of having to provide for others, I experienced some pretty bad shit that most people never know. It’s one thing to have roaches in your home, it’s a whole other thing not to have a home. Even so, my short time being houseless is nothing compared to those that spend decades that way without the use of a tent and reasonable personal safety.
- Being poor is people who have never been poor wondering why you choose to be so.
I am guilty of thinking this about the poor. Perhaps it’s because I’ve seen people dismiss their opportunities over and over. Others completely mismanaging what income does come in. People complicating their lives by making bad choice after bad choice. The great majority of poor people I knew were victims of their own behavior. People that blew all their money on name brand name junk food, cigarettes, alcohol, TVs, movie rentals and Lotto tickets. People that seem to seek out the worst possible people to be around and get taken advantage of. People that can’t keep a job they are perfectly capable of doing. People that keep producing offspring even though they can’t provide for those already here. Get a clue people, if you can’t afford clothes you can’t afford to pickup Sonic for the family!
Now, I’m not saying all poor people are this way but a great many I’ve known have suffered from one or more of the problems listed above. The other poor people? In my experience these are generally the people that life smacks in the face. Sometimes it’s one big thing like teenage birth or perhaps cancer in a spouse that leaves a lifelong struggle to recover from. Other times it seems that whatever they do they just can’t get ahead. Loss of primary provider’s job, divorce, medical problems, loss of a child, loss of retirement funds, subsequent foreclosures, bankruptcy, perhaps even a victim of Hurricane Katrina. There will always be legitimate cases that need assistance and special circumstances to account for but it seems to me if you allow these cases to create the focal point of your decision making you are losing focus on the big picture of making the best decision for the nation as a whole.
The best way to approach the poor is to become facilitators and not just throw money at the problem. I perceive the government is treating the symptom and not the problem. The government should create methods and agencies designed to provide for those that are trying to get out of the rut. Heavily regulate those businesses that feed on the suffering of the poor. Educate and provide carefully constructed solutions per individual.
I don’t think poor people want to be poor and I’m sure if you ask one, they’d much prefer to be rich. The thing about a poor person winning the lottery is that often within a few years they are back in trouble because they didn’t have the tools necessary to maintain and grow their finances.